Side-by-Side
Full Feature Comparison
The deciding factor is almost always whether you have non-spouse employees.
| Feature | Solo 401(k) | SIMPLE IRA |
|---|---|---|
Maximum Annual Contribution |
$72,000 Employee + employer combined |
$17,000 employee + required employer match |
Employee Elective Deferral |
Up to $24,500 | Up to $17,000 $18,100 if ≤25 employees |
Employer Contribution |
Up to 25% of W-2 / 20% of net SE income Discretionary — 0% is allowed |
3% match OR 2% non-elective Mandatory — cannot skip |
Age 50+ Catch-Up |
+$8,000 | +$4,000 +$5,000 if ≤25 employees |
SECURE 2.0 Super Catch-Up (60–63) |
+$11,250 | +$5,250 |
Non-Spouse Employees Allowed |
No — disqualified if hired | Yes ✓ — up to 100 |
Spouse Participation |
✓ Yes — if employed in business | ✓ Yes — treated as an employee |
Roth Option |
✓ Yes (if plan allows) | ✓ Yes (SECURE 2.0) |
Loan Provision |
✓ Yes — up to 50% / $50k | No |
Early Withdrawal Penalty |
10% + taxes | 25% in first 2 years! 10% after 2 years |
IRS Annual Filing |
Form 5500-EZ if assets > $250k | None ✓ |
Contribution Deadline |
Employee deferral: Dec 31 Employer: tax filing deadline |
Employee: per payroll Employer: 30 days after period end |
Setup Requirements |
Plan document required | IRS Form 5304-SIMPLE or 5305-SIMPLE |
RMD Start Age |
Age 73 | Age 73 |
Contribution Example
How Much Can You Contribute at $80k Net SE Income?
Assuming $80,000 net self-employment income (after the half of SE tax deduction).
💼 Solo 401(k) at $80k
🏦 SIMPLE IRA at $80k
At $80k income, the Solo 401(k) allows more than 2× the total contributions vs SIMPLE IRA. The gap is widest at moderate income levels where the employee deferral alone exceeds the SIMPLE IRA cap.
Strengths & Weaknesses
Pros & Cons
- Much higher contribution ceiling — up to $72,000 per year
- Employer contribution is fully discretionary — contribute nothing in a bad year
- Roth option (after-tax, tax-free growth)
- Loan provision — borrow up to 50% of balance or $50k
- Standard age-50 catch-up ($8,000) plus SECURE 2.0 super catch-up (60–63)
- Spouse can participate if employed in the business
- Automatically disqualified once you hire a non-spouse full-time employee
- Employee deferral election must be made by December 31 (not extendable)
- Form 5500-EZ required annually when assets exceed $250k
- Fewer brokerages offer Solo 401(k) compared to IRAs
- Works for businesses with up to 100 employees — employees can save too
- Extremely easy to set up (IRS Form 5304 or 5305 — no custom plan document)
- No annual IRS filing requirements
- Employees appreciate the salary deferral option as a workplace benefit
- SECURE 2.0 Roth SIMPLE IRA option now available
- Much lower deferral cap ($17,000 vs $24,500 for Solo 401k employee portion)
- Mandatory employer contributions — cannot skip even in a bad year
- 25% penalty on early withdrawals in the first 2 years — very harsh
- Cannot roll over to an IRA (non-SIMPLE) until 2-year participation requirement met
- Only 100-employee limit — not scalable beyond that
Decision Guide
Which Should You Choose?
- You're self-employed with no non-spouse full-time employees
- You want to maximize your annual contributions (up to $72,000)
- You want Roth contributions or a loan option
- You want flexibility to contribute $0 in lean years
- Your spouse works in the business and you want to double contributions
- You're age 50+ and want the larger catch-up ($8,000 vs $4,000)
- You have employees (other than your spouse) who need retirement coverage
- You want simplicity with no plan document or 5500 filing
- You're a small business wanting to offer employees a salary-deferral benefit
- You're comfortable with mandatory employer contributions
- You're planning to grow to more than just yourself and a spouse
FAQ
Common Questions
The Solo 401(k) is only available to businesses with no full-time employees other than the owner and their spouse. If you hire a non-spouse employee who works 1,000+ hours per year, you must transition the plan to a regular 401(k), SEP IRA, or SIMPLE IRA. You typically cannot simply exclude the new employee. Consult a plan administrator before hiring.
The 25% penalty applies only within the first 2 years of a participant's initial enrollment in the SIMPLE IRA. Congress designed this to discourage employees from immediately withdrawing funds after employers make required contributions. After 2 full years, the standard 10% early withdrawal penalty applies (like a Traditional IRA or 401k).
Generally no — not for the same business. You cannot maintain a SIMPLE IRA and a 401(k) plan simultaneously for the same employer. If you have income from a separate business (e.g., a W-2 job plus self-employment income), you might have a SIMPLE IRA through your employer and a Solo 401(k) for your side business, subject to the combined employee deferral limit of $24,500 across all plans.
Yes. Solo 401(k) contributions don't affect IRA contribution limits. You can max your Solo 401(k) at $72,000 and also contribute up to $7,500 to a Roth IRA (subject to income limits) in 2026. This combination can dramatically accelerate tax-free wealth building for self-employed individuals.