Side-by-Side
Full Feature Comparison
| Feature | SEP IRA | SIMPLE IRA |
|---|---|---|
2026 Maximum Contribution |
$72,000 | $17,000 employee + employer match |
Age 50+ Catch-Up |
No standard catch-up | +$4,000 |
Super Catch-Up (Age 60–63) |
+$11,250 | +$5,250 |
Employee Salary Deferral |
No | Yes ✓ — up to $17,000 |
Employer Contribution |
Up to 25% of W-2 / 20% of net SE | 3% match OR 2% non-elective for all |
Employer Contribution Flexible? |
Yes ✓ — 0% to 25% | Must make one of two required contributions |
Max Eligible Employees |
Unlimited | ≤ 100 employees (earned $5,000+) |
Higher Limits for Small Employers |
N/A | Yes — ≤25 employees: $18,100 deferral limit |
Early Withdrawal Penalty |
10% | 25% in first 2 years! 10% after 2 years |
Roth Option Available |
Yes (SECURE 2.0) | Yes (SECURE 2.0) |
IRS Annual Filing |
None ✓ | None ✓ |
Contribution Deadline |
Tax filing deadline incl. extensions | Employee: per payroll; Employer: 30 days after period end |
RMD Start Age |
Age 73 | Age 73 |
Compensation Limit |
$360,000 | N/A for employee deferral |
SIMPLE IRA Rules
SIMPLE IRA Employer Requirements
Every employer with a SIMPLE IRA must make one of two mandatory contributions every year.
⚠️ Unlike the SEP IRA, the employer cannot skip contributions to the SIMPLE IRA. The 3% match can be temporarily reduced to 1% (up to 2 of any 5 years), but employer contributions are mandatory.
Strengths & Weaknesses
Pros & Cons
- Massive contribution limit — up to $72,000 in 2026
- Employer contributions fully discretionary — contribute 0% in bad years
- Extended contribution deadline (can fund last year's SEP via tax extension)
- Very easy to set up — many brokerages in minutes
- Unlimited number of employees can be covered
- SECURE 2.0 super catch-up at 60–63
- Employer only — employees cannot make their own salary deferrals
- All eligible employees must receive the same contribution percentage — expensive with staff
- No separate catch-up for ages 50–59
- Immediate vesting for all employees (can be a drawback vs 401k vesting schedules)
- Employees can defer their own salary — shared savings responsibility
- Age 50+ catch-up allowed ($4,000), plus SECURE 2.0 super catch-up for 60–63
- Lower mandatory employer cost than a full 401(k)
- Easy IRS setup (Form 5304-SIMPLE or 5305-SIMPLE)
- Good for attracting employees — they can see their own deferrals
- Employee limit cap ($17,000) is much lower than SEP IRA ($72,000)
- Mandatory employer contributions — no discretion
- Only available to employers with ≤100 employees
- 25% early withdrawal penalty in first 2 years — very punitive
- Cannot contribute to another employer plan in same year (e.g., can't also have a 401k)
Decision Guide
Which Plan Is Right for Your Business?
- You're self-employed or have a very small business and want maximum savings
- You want complete flexibility to contribute 0% in lean years
- You want to contribute after the year ends (via tax extension)
- You have employees but are comfortable contributing the same % for everyone
- You want simplicity with no mandatory contributions
- You're the sole owner with income over $90k (SEP often outperforms at high incomes)
- You want employees to be able to contribute from their own paycheck
- You have ≤100 employees and want a low-cost alternative to a full 401(k)
- You want to offer a retirement benefit that attracts and retains employees
- You're comfortable with mandatory employer contributions
- You're okay with lower overall contribution limits
- You want employees to have a catch-up contribution option (age 50+)
FAQ
Common Questions
Generally no. If you have a SIMPLE IRA plan established for a business, you generally cannot also make contributions to a SEP IRA for the same business in the same year. However, if you have income from a completely separate business, you may be able to maintain separate plans. Consult a tax advisor.
Yes, but only after 2 years of plan participation. Within the first 2 years, a SIMPLE IRA can only be rolled over to another SIMPLE IRA. After 2 years, it can be rolled to a Traditional IRA, SEP IRA, Solo 401(k), or other eligible plan. Rolling early would trigger the 25% penalty plus taxes on the entire amount.
Yes. SEP IRA contributions are immediately 100% vested — employees own their account balance from day one. This differs from some 401(k) plans that can have multi-year vesting schedules. For employers trying to incentivize retention, this is a drawback; for employees, it's a benefit.
Employers using the 3% matching option can temporarily reduce it to as low as 1% — but only for 2 out of every 5 years. The employer must notify employees of the reduced rate at least 60 days before the start of the year. This provides some flexibility in difficult years without losing the plan entirely.